Comment Re:About time (Score 1) 339
(I thought your Tolkien reference needed some balance)
I would have to agree with an agency with the powers and authority of a government agency, we could call them the FBI. While that may sound a bit "snarky" it comes from a life-time (so far) of being in government service.
The problem is that going down that path may very well invoke a long habit of delegating authority (ie - delegating work). This will mean going to profit driven companies because they
1) are already in the middle
2) MUST know all about the "tubes"
3) have a vested interest in it all going well
4) already have the manpower and infrastructure in place to deal with it.
Now Walrus, I realize that you weren't suggesting this, I'm just saying that, in this country, there is a danger of it happening.
On the other hand, if an arrangement like this involved 100% exposure to the public AND had a business model that only brought income from this (in other words, NO commercial activity) this might work.
How about shooting for an entity like the US Post Office (and avoiding a situation like DHL handling being the nations postal carrier....or UPS...or FedEx...). While the USPS does collect fee's, makes a profit, etc....
1) government agency with a defined responsibility
2) have a great deal of authority within their own bailiwick
3) are 100% open to the public