Part of the reason for limiting taxation above
$87,900 is that there is - theoretically - a
retirement income benefit tied to SS, and
this benefit is capped.
I also consider $87,000 upper middle income. The data I've found makes the breakpoint for the upper 20% at $83,500.
There is no tax break being given here. The numbers in my response include income tax and FICA. The SS rate may not remain the same, but 43% of the total Social Security tax revenue was paid by those in the top 20% ( >$83,500 for 2001). 65% of all federal tax revenue was paid by the top 20%.
If you actually read the data for 2001, you'll find that about 93% of all federal tax revenue is
paid by the top 50% of workers. This breaks down to 77% of all FICA and 97% of federal income tax revenue. It is interesting that 40% of all federal revenue is FICA, but that does not mean that the lower 50% of workers are paying a disproportionate amount of federal revenue. As with all taxes, the upper 50% are paying the vast percentage of the total.