Comment High School Kids bypass Yondr with ease (Score 5, Interesting) 148
My kid's high school just implemented Yondr (after successful trials at other local schools.) It's a joke; collecting phones at the beginning of class in a cardbox box is more effective.
Kids have bought the unlocker online. Kids have figured out how to "close" the bag without it actually locking. Initially the bags were unassigned (you just picked up one at the entrance to the school) but kids would cut open the bags and/or never return them. So the school had to assign everyone a bag in order to charge for damage or loss. Even then kids cut the stitches and use tape to make the bag appear sealed. Burner/decoy phones are common. And so on.
Not having phones between classes means kids cannot coordinate clubs, e.g. notify of time updates, if someone can't make it, communicate issues, can only communicate after school gets out, etc.
Another fun problem is that a lot of kids use their phones to pay for things at the school's cafe. Because the phones are locked up when they enter school, the cafe has seen a drop off in morning customers.
Overall my high schooler says the "collect phones in a box at the start of class" is far cheaper, more convenient, faster, and more effective than Yondr.