Comment Two ideas on comment display from Reddit (Score 1) 393
Reddit has a system to base comment display and positioning on estimated asymptotic upvote rate, rather than raw scores or raw quotients. Randall Munroe from xkcd outlines the thinking here. This enables comments that are late to the party (like this one
Such quality estimators might be less important in a system with restrictive moderation caps a la Slashdot, but it illustrates a good point to consider in designing moderation systems.
Another thing Reddit does right is that "best" is not the only way to sort comments. Those who enjoy debate can choose to browse "controversial" posts instead, for instance.
In effect, Reddit recognizes that different readers have different preferences, and provides mechanisms for browsing and interaction that can accommodate these differences. This has the potential to reduce groupthink, or at least let several groups coexist and exchange information on a single site. Catering better to each individual may thus give a better site for all.