Comment Re:Playing by non-existant rules (Score 2, Insightful) 140
I agree whole heartedly.
Morals are self imposed laws drawn from culture, religion, upbringing and life experience. They vary so widely across socio groups and even generations, it would be damn near impossible to write moral law which would be acceptable to all, or even the majority. For example several christian churches define homosexuality as an immoral act. Many others would see the criminalization or persecution of homosexuals as immoral. No law can enforce both moral points of view and law should never attempt it.
The core purpose of law should be (and is supposed to be) to protect the rights and way of life of the people, not to define what is and isn't moral. The protection of every individuals right to define and live by their own morals is an essential part of this.
The beauty of living in a free country is I can have completely opposing moral views to my neighbour but still accept them as my countryman and know (hopefully) they accept me. This open diversity of opinion is what helps us grow and develop as human beings.
Law cannot both protect your right to choose and make your choices for you.
Morals are self imposed laws drawn from culture, religion, upbringing and life experience. They vary so widely across socio groups and even generations, it would be damn near impossible to write moral law which would be acceptable to all, or even the majority. For example several christian churches define homosexuality as an immoral act. Many others would see the criminalization or persecution of homosexuals as immoral. No law can enforce both moral points of view and law should never attempt it.
The core purpose of law should be (and is supposed to be) to protect the rights and way of life of the people, not to define what is and isn't moral. The protection of every individuals right to define and live by their own morals is an essential part of this.
The beauty of living in a free country is I can have completely opposing moral views to my neighbour but still accept them as my countryman and know (hopefully) they accept me. This open diversity of opinion is what helps us grow and develop as human beings.
Law cannot both protect your right to choose and make your choices for you.
