Not even close.
The looter took the television. Best Buy no longer has the television, that is theft.
"Here is an [in]appropriate analogy- let us say a looter goes into Best Buy and walks out with a flat screen TV he didn't pay for. Now he "gives" the TV to someone else. This is theft."
If you wanted to restate your analogy, so that it was in fact analogous to people trading music on p2p networks it would be more along the lines of:
"- let us say a looter goes into Best Buy with a digital recorder and tapes the music being played in the store that he didn't pay for. Now he "gives" copies of this to someone else. This isn't theft"
Actually I believe that would be legal... Hmm let me try again.
"- let us say a looter goes into Best Buy with a digital camcorder and tapes the movie being played in the store that he didn't pay for. Now he "gives" copies of this to someone else. This isn't theft"
Taping a show (not in a movie theater, that was recently criminalized :( ) is still legal, darn, I guess I'l have to try again.
"- let us say a looter goes into Best Buy with a laptop and rips the music from a music cd-rom (in an already opened package)that was played in the store that he didn't pay for. Now he "gives" copies of this to someone else. This isn't theft"
Finally, a way to make your Best Buy looter analogous to people trading files on p2p networks.... no wait that isn't quite right. I think I can get it right this time.
"- let us say a looter goes into Best Buy with a laptop and rips a CD-ROM containing music that he _paid_ for. Now he "gives" copies of this to someone else. This isn't theft, but it is copyright infringement"
There you go, a proper analogy. The only problem with an example that is truely analogous is that it still doesn't seem all that bad. Makes you wonder why this is illegal. It wasn't always illegal. It still isn't _theft_. Perhaps instead of arresting people for doing what never was, untill recently, either a problem or illegal, we should simply change the law to reflect what people do.
Naw, if we started doing that, how would the RIAA and there ilk make oodles of money? What's next, decriminalizing the growing of plants? Where will the maddness end?!?
someone247356