Journal sielwolf's Journal: The Canon ('81 - '01) 88
I've been thinking about this part of the James Murphy article:
At the same time, I get really angry when people get angry about there being a canon. White Male Canon thing. I always thought a canon's a great way to start cause then we can argue against it. The internet, I read a story on the internet-- "Fuck Shakespeare." What? That's an interesting argument only because you have Shakespeare. If you don't have that canon, there's nothing to talk about, there's total chaos... But being past all of that, I had to find what I loved about music, I had to dig farther... I think a canon is important, but you have to grow into it.
So, shall we define the canon then? Post at the top and comment below each defending or flaming each.
The only rules:
- The Canon SHALL COVER only 1981 to 2001. Before that everything is kinda nostalgic and pre-singularity of music that Mr Murphy talked about. This is the tough era where the indies exploded the number of choices. And anything within the last four years is a bit of a wash (i.e. no perspective).
- The Canon SHALL contain Albums Only. This kind of slants it against hip-hop, techno and other club genres but that's the breaks. The problem is if we start saying how important a single is, an album can be included just because it had one good song instead of being front to back important.
Other thoughts:
- The Canon SHOULD be as small as possible. None of this "Put in the entire Minutemen's catalog". That's lazy and cheap. The idea is that someone should be able to grok the entire last 20 years of music in the least amount of albums.
- The Canon SHOULD NOT be determined by mainstream or critical appeal. Does Nevermind belong in here? Or is it more of a yardstick (i.e. the maypole everyone danced around, burning their Mr Big discs to)? This should be shit people would pop in the deck in their car or in their house. Not mere historical oddities that gather dust. However...
- The Canon SHOULD NOT be a desert island list. Well, not exactly. Loving an album is important but putting it on here because it was audio panty remover doesn't cut it.
Other than that, gouge away.
Depeche Mode - Violator (Score:2)
Re:Depeche Mode - Violator (Score:2)
Favorite DM track of all time though is Shake the Disease.
Portishead - Dummy (Score:2)
Nobody loves me, it's true.
Metallica - ...And Justice for All (Score:2)
Beastie Boys - Paul's Boutique (Score:2)
Funny. Now Missy Elliott quotes "Copywritten so don't copy me". Ironic as the sample and the break form the foundation of her very bread an
Skinny Puppy - Too Dark Park (Score:2)
And it is almost clubworthy. Not any violent 'scapes of noise here. Ensare
A Tribe Called Quest - Midnight Marauders (Score:2)
Wrong. Every gat pulled, switched flipped there was a strong bluesy complete portrait. "Award Tour" set off the transformation: from the Jungle Brothers afrocentrism of the late '80s to the new reality of the '90s. The cool was not just a hard image backed up with harsh possibilities. The collec
Re:A Tribe Called Quest - Midnight Marauders (Score:2)
Aquiring Midnight Marauders as we speak to see what I missed. Lost interest after Bonita Applebum and Left my wallet in el segundo a few years earlier.
De La is Dead? (Score:1)
KRS-One: Sound of da Police? (Score:1)
What about "The Coming" by Busta? Or is it enough to have the Leaders of the New on "Scenario"?
And YO, SCENARIO is def-tip shot out the 'canon' baby!
DAMN.
How 'bout the ROOTS?
And what about "STRAIGHT OUTTA COMPTON"? (and include GWAR "scumm dogs" as a rider to that)
And What PE? "Fear of a black Planet"?
Re:KRS-One: Sound of da Police? (Score:2)
I don't think The Coming. His thing was covered by being sort of the wacky crossmember between Tribe and Biggie. I love his album but it isn't canonical.
The Roots... I could see that. But which: Illadeph, DYWM?, Things Fall Apart?
Re:KRS-One: Sound of da Police? (Score:1)
Well, I wanted to dialog some stuff out under TRIBE before adding them up top.
YEs, I believe "Scenario" covers it.
For The Roots, I'm thinking Illadelph 1/2; but do you have any arguments in favor of Do you want more?
Re:KRS-One: Sound of da Police? (Score:2)
For The Roots, I'm thinking Illadelph 1/2; but do you have any arguments in favor of Do you want more?
Hmmm, I always found the two a push. I always liked "? vs. Rahzel" but for more of a freestyle expo sen
Re:KRS-One: Sound of da Police? (Score:1)
You say that like its a bad thing that would preclude one from inclusion into Teh Cannonxz0rz.
I dunno, I think it was really hype; lots of people loved it, and is a definite snapshot in time.
But Charlie Brown and that other dude just never made it.
hahaha! Dinko D probably LOVES hearing that! (its true...)
Re:KRS-One: Sound of da Police? (Score:2)
Oh yeah, and "Illmatic". n/t (Score:1)
Re:KRS-One: Sound of da Police? (Score:2)
Yea gotta have Public Enemy in the Canon somewhere.
The question is should it be It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back or Fear of a Black Planet?
It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back was the breakthrough album that changed hip-hop forever. But Fear of a Black Planet is Public Enemy at their musical and artistic peak.
(As a side note I must say I'm not much of a rap or hip-hop fan. What I do like tends to be considered old skool and is mostly East Coa
U2 - Joshua Tree (Score:2)
1. Where The Streets Have No Name
2. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For
3. With Or Without You
4. Bullet The Blue Sky
DM's Black Celebration was also in heavy rotation at my house, as well as Kissing to be clever. Boy George is a musical genius, and I have gay taste in music.
Re:U2 - Joshua Tree (Score:2)
LP? Record player? :)
Re:U2 - Joshua Tree (Score:2)
Heh (Score:2)
I was thinking about posting something like Paul Abdul's, "Forever Your Girl" and trying to be all serious, but that kind of thing is beyond being typed with a straight face.
Re:Heh (Score:2)
Re:Heh (Score:2)
It's been so long, and I am so old, I can't remember anymore. The only video I remember is the Opposites Attract one with that animated cat. How sad.
Re:Heh (Score:2)
Ahh, making fun of celebs is fun. I'd hit it though.
Re:Heh (Score:2)
Wow, you really made that joke your own.
Re:Heh (Score:2)
Pantera - Vulgar Display of Power (Score:2)
DJ Shadow - Endtroducing..... (Score:2)
"Changeling" How many songs do you know that have a 15/16 time structure? "Building Steam from a Grain of Salt", "Midnight in a Perfect World". Kind of like Pantera,
Aphex Twin - I Care Because You Do (Score:2)
The expectations of what electronic music were had changed. There was that complexity to "Digerridoo" and "Polynomial-C" that let people the song was one or the other. But here?
It starts on the perfect tone. It pierces right through "Acrid Avid Jam Shred". That wonderful burbling drum break that sounds like a straight two bar split but comes up with a wonderful complexity sort of dancing on the edges. It was part classical beauty of Brahms ("The Waxen Pith")
Re:Aphex Twin - I Care Because You Do (Score:1)
i'm such a dork that i actually slowed the track down to about 90 bpm. the resemblance to boards of canada is pretty uncanny. the pitch-bent sound doesn't really fit with BoC, but the structure, both harmonic and rhythmic, is just like BoC.
if you don't have a wave editor i'll happily email it to you for comparison.
Re:Aphex Twin - I Care Because You Do (Score:2)
Michael Jackson - Thriller (Score:2)
Bad kind of floats. But this here is just. Goddamn. Remember when Pop music was like this?
The album that taught people how zombies dance. Shit, you break out that leather thing and start doing that junkie shoulder jerk? GAME OVER.
Re:Michael Jackson - Thriller (Score:2)
For some reason when I think of this album I can't help remembering Weird Al's Eat It video. That one still brings a smile to my face.
Joy Division - Closer (Score:2)
"A Means to an End" is my jam. This might be the perfect song.
Re:Joy Division - Closer (Score:2)
I can think of quite a few albums from say '78, '79, and '80 that had much to do with defining the sound for the next 25 year or so.
Off the top of my head The Police's Zenyatta Mondatta, Talking Heads' Remain in Light, Van Halen's Van Halen, David Bowie's Scary Monsters, The Clash's London Calling, or Blondie's Parallel Lines all deserve mention.
Re:Joy Division - Closer (Score:2)
If Closer's out, I guess we go with NO Power, Corruption & Lies. "Age of Consent" and "Your Silent Face".
I'd also think Bowie Let's Dance might be more appropriate to the decade. Then you get some retroactiveness with "China Girl".
VH 1984 might be a good pick. But it might have to be offset with Motley Crue or something.
Sepultura - Roots (Score:2)
Rage Against the Machine were a bunch of Ivy League wangs. This is the real agitpop. System of a Down should be thanking their lucky stars. Brazilian jungle monstrosity. Out of the industrial Amazonian slag pit of Sao Paulo. Miles and miles of slums so bloody that the rich go to work in Helicopters.
This is indigenous uprising. AIM. Ab
Nominations (Score:2)
The Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and The Infinite Sadness
Dr. Dre - Chronic
Michael Jackson - Thriller
Garth Brooks - Ropin' the Wind
U2 - The Joshua Tree
Jay-Z - Hard Knock Life, Vol. 2
Metallica - Metallica
Aphex Twin - I Care Because You Do
Beastie Boys - License to Ill
Re:Nominations (Score:2)
Dr. Dre - Chronic
Beastie Boys - License to Ill
Got no problem with that.
Jay-Z - Hard Knock Life, Vol. 2
Metallica - Metallica
Hmmm. I guess my thinking is that there's a debate about Jay's Vol. 2 and Reasonable Doubt as to which is better, making it hard to chose one or the other. And even those get paired up against Illmatic, The Infamous and Ready to Die. It is a part of the genre but not out there defining that New York counterpoint to West Coast G-funk. Not that all
Re:Nominations (Score:2)
1. Huge commercial success, launching an empire of Roca-related things. Many would do this, Carter and Dash probably did it the best.
2.Floss. Big time. It changed the direction of attention while still keeping the newyork attitude of importance of flow and narrative.
The other thing is my list is only like half comp
Re:Nominations (Score:2)
I'd say Nirvana's Bleach or Nevermind were far more signifigant. Without Nirvana alt-rock would likely still be stuck in a college radio ghetto. It is easy to forget that Cobain was quite likely one of the best rock songwriters of the last 30 years with all of the hype and mythology surrounding both him and Nirvana. For me it is hard to choose between Bleach or Nevermind as being the more signifigant album. Bleach has all of the core elements t
Re:Nominations (Score:2)
Re:Nominations (Score:2)
The money they made off Nirvana and the other bands in their catalog that hit it big around that time let them develop a lot more stuff and do a much better job at promotion of the artists they signed.
Note that Sub Pop is still around, still independent and still signing local bands.
Then again perhaps my impressions are colored by being aquainted with some of the people who were working at Sub Pop back in the day.
Also that I believe
Eric B & Rakim - Paid in Full (Score:2)
Consider how many MCs were name dropping Tommy or Bo Jackson. What was once "Oooh!" became "Ugh *eyes roll" to "Huh?" This foundation, on the disposable party jam, met its match with Rakim Allah.
With some guy from the Bronx called KRS-One, Rakim elevated
Wu-tang Clan - Enter the Wu tang (36 Chambers) (Score:2)
"Redrum. I verbally assault with the tongue. Murder One. My style shocks, knocks you out like a stun gun"
Nothing was really ever the same since. That harsh cartoon horn, the finger snaps. The breaks that seemed to escape out of the very earth. The Wu-tang was completel
Dr. Octagon - Dr. Octagynecologyst (Score:2)
R.E.M. - Automatic for the People (Score:2)
Sade - Diamond Life (Score:2)
Dead Kennedys - Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetables (Score:2)
It's everything that good music is. Funny. Fast. Furious. Biting. Hard. Non-repetitive. Clever. Loud. Intelligent. Revolutionary.
Kill the Poor ! Lynch the Landlord ! California Uber Alles ! I Kill Children ! Holiday in Cambodia !
Dead Kennedys kick ass a baker'
Re:Dead Kennedys - Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetab (Score:1)
Black Flag - Damaged (Score:2)
Of course this album is more important than just making Henry Rollins Hollywood career...
And you want to know why?
Let's just say a little label called SST. Funny, idiotic, juvenille, angry. Punk should've been a progression from this, the Stooges and, I dunno, HD. Both musically and fiscally. *Checks the hardcore playing on Headbanger's Ball* How did we end up here?
einstürzende neubauten (Score:1)
strategies against architecture II also contains those songs in one version or another, but also covers much more of the essentials from the early neubauten years. either that's cheating or it's craftily taking what's important from t
Re:einstürzende neubauten (Score:2)
front 242 (Score:1)
pixies (Score:1)
you think i'm dead, but i sail away on a wave of mutilation.
Re:pixies (Score:2)
Both are good though.
I'm also thinking Husker Du needs an entry, both because their stuff was good and for the influence it had on 90's alt-rock.
Re:pixies (Score:1)
yeah, i remember hüsker dü.
Re:pixies (Score:2)
Certainly Surfer Rosa counts as the Pixies breakthrough and was probably somewhat more influential. Now if it or Dolittle were the better album is subject to debate. I lean toward Surfer Rosa but only because I'm more familiar with it.
Re:pixies (Score:1)
meat beat manifesto (Score:1)
they might be giants (Score:1)
why are we marching hand in hand?
why are the ocean levels rising up?
it's a brand new record for 1990
they might be giants brand new album, flood
Re:they might be giants (Score:2)
He is our hero.
Re:they might be giants (Score:1)
Wow, flood of memories (Score:2)
"Spider, he is our hero.", "Spider, musssht stop!"
That so takes me back to high school. Being embarassed by my friends that were singing it in line for Taco Bell in our cafeteria. Weird.
the future sound of london (Score:1)
Ministry - Psalm 69 (TWTS&TWTSE) (Score:2)
But Psalm 69 is so definitive. The guitar blitzkreig of "N.W.O", the title cut, "Just One Fix" with Burroughs in the video, Gibby in "Jesus Built My Hotrod". It was political, all about heroin, apocolyptic. Dark satire. "Scarecrow" is fat wide and mean. This was a
Re:Ministry - Psalm 69 (TWTS&TWTSE) (Score:2)
Photek - K.J.Z (Score:1)
oh yes my high and mighty selecta raise it up raise it up and rinse it out!
Doc Scott "shadowboxing" (Score:1)
I'd also nominate Congo Natty's "Junglist" in both the Ragga and Jump Up category. Perhaps not as influencial as "Shadowboxing", this was still certainly the jam and could be considered representative.
Maybe even Adam F's "Circles"...
Re:Doc Scott "shadowboxing" (Score:2)
Re:Doc Scott "shadowboxing" (Score:1)
Then maybe just the Roni Size "Breakbeat Era" single (not their album Ultraobscene, which is totally fucking overproduced)- because its also got an "amen" version!
speaking of goldie/playford; what about "Innercity life"? Its been played ta' fuck out, but does the very fact that its included on an MTV comp give i
What it means to be Canon (Score:2)
But then I also thought that it might be more like the following: at 11:59 pm, December 30, 1980 an astronaut is shot into space to, I dunno, fly around the rings of Saturn. This is a 20 year journey where he will only have communication with the controllers at NASA. At precisely 12:00 am, January 1, 2002 he touches down at Edwards AFB, jumps out of his spacecraf
Air - Moon Safari (Score:2)
The cooldown aesthetic found an impossible continental edge here. There is no Zero 7 without
Phish - Picture of Nectar (Score:2)
Duran Duran - Rio (Score:2)
Legendary
Prince - Sign "O" the Times (Score:2)
Ok, now you can listen to this masterpiece. Perfect Paisley Park material. This is when Prince was on some next level Charlie and the Chocolate Factory thing. You had this sense that there was some magical purple palace out there where they made this unbelievable music. All wierdly costumed
Re:Prince - Sign "O" the Times (Score:2)
Purple Rain probably gets the nod over 1999 because it was more of a concept album but still not too weird.
Still I can't argue with your selection of Sign 'O' the Times as most critics think that album is where he hit his artistic peak.
Mid '80s pop (Score:2)
The problem is I really can't say what the definative album of this sort of pop/new wave is.
Suggestions anyone?
Re:Mid '80s pop (Score:2)
There's also a need for Whitney Houston or Janet. Probably Def Leopard, maybe Motley Crue.
The KLF (Score:2)
Chill Out for being one of the pioneering ambient house albums. Though I have to admit this is among my least favorite of The KLF's work, but then I'm not much for ambient either.
White Room for being a classic acid house album and the successful culmination of the scam that was the KLF.
If I had to pick one I'd make the nod to White Room but only because it is among my favorite albums.
Re:The KLF (Score:2)
Truly it was a classic, but not really acid house, no.
Unfortunately, there aren't really any "acid house" albums that aren't compilations, so it seems hard to come up with something to fit that. Or did Phuture release an album in a limited edition of 50 or something?
Re:The KLF (Score:2)
I'd heard "White Room" refered to as 'British House' or 'Acid House' so I went with that.
Re:The KLF (Score:2)
The Art of Noise - (Who's Afraid Of?) (Score:2)
Synth-pop meets eletronica, meets found sound, meets sampling with a bunch of off the wall twists.
Radiohead - The Bends (Score:2)
Pablo Honey was the unsure footsteps of a ten month old. Too excited with an American sound, the sort of mockery that defined Bush.
But The Bends... was an album. It was a classic Anglo melancholy... or does it just seem that way now? "Fake Plastic Trees", "Just". When the early 90's euphoria die
So here's what's missing (Score:2)
The Orb - Adventures Beyond the Ultraworld. The REAL ambient dub/house kickoff. And yeah, LX and that Pastie guy were working together before that, so the KLF gets props too, but they're already on the list, eh?
Kate Bush - The Dreaming. KaTe inspired piano driven singer-songwriters like Tori & Fiona just to name a couple I like... It's a hard choice between The Dreaming and Hounds of Love, but I think the earlier album has more oomph.
Elvis Costello - Imperial Be
Smiths "Queen is dead" (Score:1)
Okay, maybe not Mr. McFerrin run-away hit.
Nicky Blackmarket and Stevie Hyper D (Score:1)
Not sure if this is even a real album, but I've got the jam on MP3.
Why?
I think its the be-all end all of the jump-up/ragga with dope mc'ing (is believing) on top of it. Just 45 minutes, and you've got it. The feel, the mix, the rewinds, the lingo ("Wheel up my selecta!"), and toasts ("to the east, to the west, to the nort, to the south jungle is forever and them can't run we out stevie hype upon the mic and i'm a screaming and shout, Nicky Blackmarket another rinse out!"). Done and Done.
Ju