Comment So... (Score 1) 42
It's funny how people will say "People want this, because it's easier!" and also "People don't want to use Linux, because it's harder!"
I recall watching a movie where some thugs crash a party where a bunch of rich people were and he demanded everyone hand over wallets, jewelry, and cell phones. That movie was from 1995, and even with the movie that old I thought the phones back then would have the ability for remote disabling.
I always thought the point of that was so that nobody called the cops before they were gone. Bricking aside, I don't know how useful stolen cellphones would have been in 1995? Compared to today when everyone has one so there's a market for working used parts, and you can easily get paid for recycling them.
This is a child's toy.
Yes, I saw that you said that. My response was based on you saying that.
One can't even begin to seriously protect children without supervision.
Yes, but we don't entrust that supervision to random, unknown people for a reason.
We all know children are not properly supervised when around random men online.
So how can random men online be the supervision?
Life guards are big brother! Police at large gatherings are big brother! Hall monitors are big brother!
I didn't say the act of recording itself was 1984 shit. And I don't want lifeguards recording my kids as they swim and sending the videos off to their unseen bosses to judge if they're drowning. (Sure, my kids could just not swim if I don't want that, but that's bullshit, my kids should be able to swim.) Hall monitors, when they're not other kids, have to pass background checks (though I know, passing that just means a person hasn't been caught doing something) and have the community watching to make sure they're not pervs.
The police... okay actually, that may be a good analogy. We can't even keep pervs and abusers out of the police force, how do you expect we can keep them out of the Nintendo moderation team? Who has access to their body cam footage? What are they doing with the footage of children? All of this actually is a big deal that we talk about without being accused of being a perv.
This reeks of over simplification or rationalization by a perv.
Yeah, the only reason I could see an issue with children being recorded and potentially watched by random unknown, unseen people is if I'm a perv.
If we put cameras into bathrooms they'd be much nicer
But I'm the one that reeks of being a perv.
I have a problem with children broadcasting anything precisely because you can't control what anyone does at the other end.
So then you should be protesting the very existence of GameChat, which is encouraging children to broadcast themselves? I mean personally I do think the whole thing is a horrible idea in the first place because of the problems with children broadcasting themselves at all, and I really don't think anyone asked for it.
Your argument is like saying Twitch shouldn't record streams because there might be children in them.
Nope; when your child does a Twitch stream, you EXPECT that it will be recorded and broadcast out to you-dont-know-who. Also Twitch has some pretty strict rules about minors, and easy ways for parents to remove a minor's recordings from the Twitch servers. (Obviously that doesn't stop viewers that have recorded it themselves, but you can't stop that in a video chat either. Although actually in this case, Nintendo has the power to delete recordings from people's consoles - though obviously not if it's been backed up somewhere else. Are they going to do that?) If kids are going to be banned from GameChat when it's apparent they're using it without adult supervision, as is done on Twitch if someone notices, then maybe my opinion on it will change; but I highly doubt that's going to be the case.
What steps is Nintendo taking to ensure that the moderators aren't creeps? How are they going to deal with it if say, they get sent a video of a naked minor? Those are some of the problems I'm talking about. I never suggested all reporting functions be removed, I just don't think GameChat as it appears to be now is a good idea. How about you fuck off with "if you speak up against it you must be a creep supporter" bullshit.
On a paper submitted by a physicist colleague: "This isn't right. This isn't even wrong." -- Wolfgang Pauli