Comment No, homework should stay (Score 1) 192
One of our kids went to a middle school where they were a "no homework" policy. The reason? Some kids didn't have parents to hold their feet to the fire to get it done - socioeconomic problems, home/life/work issues, etc. So it was considered an "equalization" tactic.
This would all be fine, if everywhere, including private institutions, everything was equal. But it's not, and neither is the kind of education kids receive both on and off campus. Certain things require extra effort outside of the school system. Taking homework away from the kids also left us playing liar's poker each day to figure out what they did in class, and/or how do we know if they actually understand the topic.
I'm sure teachers don't want to take loads of homework on any more either. There's not a teacher I've met in the last 10 years who isn't required to do some absurd level of extra school stuff at all times... I'm pretty sure most work 50+ hours a week at a bare minimum. I can totally see why they would love to have no homework as a policy.
Perhaps if people are going to live to be 85+ years old, and thanks to advances in AI and the like have to be continually trained and re-trained for various things over time, we should stop this mad race to get kids through school and into college or the workforce by 17. The promise of "good jobs" and "careers" is entirely broken at this point - kids are still going through the motions to prove their worth somehow to society, but with fewer and fewer rewards for their efforts.
This would all be fine, if everywhere, including private institutions, everything was equal. But it's not, and neither is the kind of education kids receive both on and off campus. Certain things require extra effort outside of the school system. Taking homework away from the kids also left us playing liar's poker each day to figure out what they did in class, and/or how do we know if they actually understand the topic.
I'm sure teachers don't want to take loads of homework on any more either. There's not a teacher I've met in the last 10 years who isn't required to do some absurd level of extra school stuff at all times... I'm pretty sure most work 50+ hours a week at a bare minimum. I can totally see why they would love to have no homework as a policy.
Perhaps if people are going to live to be 85+ years old, and thanks to advances in AI and the like have to be continually trained and re-trained for various things over time, we should stop this mad race to get kids through school and into college or the workforce by 17. The promise of "good jobs" and "careers" is entirely broken at this point - kids are still going through the motions to prove their worth somehow to society, but with fewer and fewer rewards for their efforts.