Comment Re: It's all about definitions. (Score 5, Insightful) 177
It's right in the name: grade. As in "gradation". The intention of grades is to stack rank. Any system that results in all A's is not a grading system; it's a certification system.
Function over form. Defined that way it makes it just about whether you're lucky enough to be in a year full of dumb people and is rather unhelpful in finding the best candidate for any employer because it doesn't preserve year on year boundaries. The only exception might be if you're only recruiting new grads from the milkround. The smartest person in one year with an A might be the dumbest when compared to their fellow students in the next year. I swear the only people advocating for this system are the ones who have a desperate need to feel the best in their peer group, rather than actually caring about how useful the system is.