Comment Let's kill the straw men. (Score 1) 260
These contests, as focused as they are, are indeed vulnerable to attack when that focus is recast as tunnel vision. While it is true that most of the effort in a a software project is figuring out the right question to ask, the performance on a well-structured problem _does_ have value. It seems disingenuous for a misdirection towards less measurable skills, it allows 'I could do that just as well' to be plausible, just not to me. As someone who has proven worthy in these contests, and having been faced with naysayers, I have found that when I try to figure out what other aspects are important, I find that others have no real clue what they want, yet they blame me for not delivering it.