Comment Re:Do a study FIRST. (Score 2) 90
1) This is stupid.
Are we supposed to run some study to figure out that a stopped truck with warning lights around it is safer than one without? Let me rephrase. Are _you_ willing to shoulder the cost of the victims of the negative case? No? Of course not.
What about the criminal cost? You just did demand that some people should die either way to prove one, right? You're okay with going to jail for demanding that some people die to prove your point, of course! No? Of course not.
Are _you_ going to run the test one thousand time, see if you crash more in the truck with lights or without? No? Of course not.
Since you're not a scientist, you should know that _proper_ scientific studies include an ethical aspect. So, for instance, you can't just kill people to "scientifically" prove something anyone with half a brain cell already knows. Such as in this case.
2) Allow some leeway for reality, flares, paces, whatever, next thing some idiot is complaining it's all just as bad as nothing. You do realize you're arguing for more stringent regulations with no regard for what's possible, yeah?
3) Company does study that "shows" their business model is sound. Yeah. You were harping on earlier about "medically tested science". I'm not actually sure what you mean by that. That someone should evaluate the damage to individual organs, instead of accident vs no accident, to come up with some conclusion about whether cones or no cones are better? Or do you think "medically tested science" is the gold standard? Well, it's not. If you're coming from physics, p 0.01 is laughable. Medical science is not about a single paper proving the point (well, sometimes it is, when the paper proves the point _wrong_). It's about multiple papers about different experiments that imply the same conclusion. Anyway. Run studies, get the rules changed, and you're off! What this "we don't think the rules apply to us"? If you _actually truly believe_ that the rules are wrong _and you can prove it_, you argue for them being changed, not for an exemption.
4) Again, make some leeway for practicality, next thing some idiot is complaining it's all just as bad as nothing.