Comment Re:Cringeworthy (Score 1) 175
It is about proportionality. For most of your life you will not actually need ID to do any of those things. True, young adults will need ID from 18 until their mid-20s or so. But in those cases you show your ID to a single person, who will check the photo and birth date with their human eyes and hand it back to you. This is a far cry from sending identity data to a remote server of questionable repute, after which you have no idea what will happen to it. You would really be happy to give a site like 4chan or some random porn site your ID? That's what the government is demanding we do. This is not a remotely equivalent situation to buying age restricted products in real life and actually extremely dangerous.
A much better solution is for parents to make sure the devices they are giving to their children are safe for them to use. Now you can argue "parents are too stupid for that to work". But I did not say 'do nothing', I said teach parents what they need to do. I think most take their kids welfare seriously and so will be on board. The government can also help by, for example. mandating that new phones come pre-loaded with parental controls enabled by default and a clear and easy set-up flow parents can use before they hand the device to their child. Doing this also makes it much harder for the child to work around as they will not be able to install VPN software without parental approval.
As for your last point there is a reason for Article 8 in the ECHR. If you want to make every aspect of your life public then go ahead nobody will stop you. However, we have a right not to do that and to not be compelled to do that.