Comment Re:"Can you please turn off the filters?" (Score 0) 585
Just chiming in here. I can see valid points to all arguments. It is true that libraries are not *required* to accept Federal funding (although it makes life a lot easier for the library administrator to be "guaranteed" a reliable source of income each year via E-rate funding), the possible lost of that income will force many libraries to install inadequate filters (which will be paid for out of local funds, not Federal funds - the "unfunded mandate" mentioned). Libraries in PA are historically "free" (thank you Ben Franklin!), though many have instituted fees for some non-traditional library services (such as inter-library loan). Librarians, who are, for the most part, exceptionally service-oriented people, are offended (some may say rightfully) when asked to curtail or charge for the service that they have happily been providing for free. To them, it's all about making the patron (the end-user) happy and satisfied when he/she walks out the door. The ability to supply what the patron needs/wants is paramount in good library service. CIPA will require all computers in a public library that receives Federal funds be filtered. The current crop of filtering software is barely adequate for the job. (any programmers or software engineers out there, here's your chance - write it well, and they will come!) Libraries will be forced to commit precious resources to purchase/license and maintain those filters, taking those resources away from other vital services, such as electricity, water, heat, air conditioning.
I agree that it is the responsibility of every community to support its local library, but many communities are disadvantaged and rely on state/Federal support to help with library service.
I can just imagine if the library had to close and all 55,000 library users were to arrive at Barnes and Noble to read their favorite books. I doubt very much that B&N would allow them through the door.
I agree that it is the responsibility of every community to support its local library, but many communities are disadvantaged and rely on state/Federal support to help with library service.
I can just imagine if the library had to close and all 55,000 library users were to arrive at Barnes and Noble to read their favorite books. I doubt very much that B&N would allow them through the door.