Re:This problem has killed Roleplaying imho (Score 1)

What you describe here, is pretty much exactly how Saga of Ryzom works. Quoted from their website www.ryzom.com "Planet Atys is a living world, with five rich and diverse ecosystems. A powerful AI technology makes flora and fauna interact dynamically with each other and the ever-changing environment. Admittedly the game did go under, but has recently been revived. It has one of the most "loving" communities i've ever seen in a MMORPG..