That's what we're talking about here. It's not even right or wrong it's a lack of jurisdiction.
Actually that's not at all what the parent post is saying. The parent post which was modded "5" as insightful, argues that anything that can be copied for no cost should have no value, regardless of the laws around it. My post addressed that argument, but, of course this being slashdot, got modded troll because god forbid anyone should disagree with the fucking geniuses on this site that think they know everything about economics and law, and believe that communications companies should be able to charge a service fee for distributing work created by artists who shouldn't get anything for their efforts. You people make me fucking sick.