Some considerations:
First of all, Google (the branch) is incorporated in Brazil, so by law it is a Brazilian company and has to follow Brazilian laws. This is way different than claiming jurisdiction because of nothing more than a top level domain, without any other kind of presence, like the US does. Google is a legal company in Brazil, with local offices, executives, employees and engineers and offers products in Brazil, in Portuguese, using a
Second of all, the law is ridiculous and it is from decades ago, pre-Internet and made to control the message since politicians or their close allies own most of TV and paper media in Brazil. This kind of law makes no sense in a world with Internet and user-generated content.
But, having said that, I also think that a company has to comply with the laws and especially with a court order. (They can dispute in court if they don't like it, but they cannot pick and choose what to comply.) And the appropriate response for not following the laws or for contempt is arresting the top executive (not a sales droid like some other posts imply) of said company. I just wish we were as severe to punish misdeeds from companies as severely as when we are trying to enforce a ridiculous and arcane law from the 50-60s.
Remember, the executive is not being punished for the video, which is sadly illegal under the current laws (the author if found is liable for defamation, libel and breaking the electoral law). The top executive is being held responsible for his company not removing the video (blocking it until after the election was also an acceptable solution mentioned in the court order) when requested by a lawful court order and given one week to comply.
The current situation in Argentina reminds me of Brazil before Plano Real when inflation was around 60% per month and people where running for the dollar. Some years before that the government froze 80% of the bank assets of the whole population, which was a total disaster.
In retrospect, it is amazing that Plano Real actually worked. I'm still amazed when I think about it: I was born in 1980 and in my lifetime I've seen Brazil adopt 6 different currencies! New governments would announce over the weekend that the currency have been renamed and three zeros have been cut (1000 = 1); until new banknotes were available the banks were stamping the old ones with the new name and value. Prices and contracts were frozen; it was a mess...
Even today many people still go to the supermarket and buy groceries for the whole month, out of habit. In the old times of hyper-inflation, you had to rush to the supermarket and buy everything you could because if you went in the morning and later went again in the same day but during the afternoon instead, prices would have changed already. When I was a young kid, and before we had barcode scanners and a ticket with the price was fixed in every piece of merchandise, supermarkets had full-time employees that spend their whole day attaching the new prices. I remember that I ran more than once to grab something in the end of a long corridor while the employee was setting the new prices at the other end, so I could pay the old price before he had the opportunity to change it.
If Brazil managed to fix that mess I bet Argentina can, too. It might take a while, though: it took us more than two decades.
That is exactly what I thought: is 6 cups a day normal?? What's the normal size for a cup in U.S.? I'm from Brazil and we like strong coffee here; I heard that Americans coffee is weaker, that might also be an explanation.
I agree with some points you make, but being a Brazilian who lives in Sweden and works in Denmark I can say that I have intimate knowledge of both "Brazilian-style" and "Europen-style" socialisms. Brazil can indeed teach a lot of lessons to the Europeans, but we're still far away from a place like Sweden. We are advancing, that's a fact, but in a very slow pace compared to what we could achieve according to our size and resources.
Why do everybody have this idea of topless ladies in Brazil? It's considered indecent exposure, and you can go to jail for that. Europe in fact is much more liberal in this regard.
Ask me about Loom.
-- Pirate Cobb
What this country needs is a good five cent ANYTHING!