Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Someone (Score 4, Insightful) 98

Speaking as a European observer I see that Trump's actions have killed a lot of people and put many other peoples lives in danger. Of course we feel a bit deranged about that. I do hope all good Americans, on either side of the political isle can get that monster out of power as soon as possible.

Comment Re:MIT vs GPL (Score 1) 190

What kind of logic is that? There is not ing about the GPL that does not promote ones code being used as widely as possible. Literally anyone can use it.

The only restriction is in distribution, so you are not talking about use but distribution. The GPL clearly encourages distribution.

Comment Re:Uhh... Cool? (Score 2) 190

But wait, a document describing in enough detail how the original code works is a derived work of the original.
A copy of that document to another machine is clearly also a derived work.
Writing new code from that document is a derived work of the document which is a derived work of the original code.

Now, derived works are not allowed by copyright unless one has license.

Comment Re: Will AI ever make it better/more-secure? (Score 1) 26

As a European observer I cannot see how you come to the idea it will all be liberals fault when the whole AI industry is driven by Republicans from Trump/Musk downwards. They are the ones openly trying to sell us their technology that will make the human race extinct. I don't see any liberals in this picture so far.

Comment Re:AI works, really well (Score 2, Insightful) 45

Grey hair here. Stop being agist. It's silly and stupid and the assumption you have made there is not true anyway. Plenty of us are generating code with AI for a long time already. In fact a few of us even created the possibility of doing so.

Now, about that AI generated libc you would trust. I have to ask why you would trust it?

Presumably you are not going to review all the C or whatever language code it is compiled from. Even if you tried it may well be so contorted and unfathomable you would not be any wiser. So you can't put your trust in that.

As you should know it is impossible to trust the correctness of code by testing. All kind of bad behaviour can get by testing as we know from all the security issues we find in old code all the time.

In AI gen. world programming language source code is replace by prompts as the upstream source. Which we typically do not keep. And even if we did there is no way you could create the same code from the same prompts again. So we can't trust that either.

So what is it you are trusting when I give you my AI generated libc?

 

Comment Re:Still linux just stolen... (Score 1) 88

I'm pretty sure that when most human coders write some code they are incorporating bits of all the things they have learned from all over the place for years. From books, from tutorials, from Stackoverflow, from source code they have worked on previously or just studied to educate themselves.

I find it hard to believe that most coder just magically know how to code out of nothing. No, it comes from all their past experience.

Why then is it "theft" in your mind when we automate this process with a machine but not if a human does it?

I can think of many reasons not to be happy about AI generated code but the theft idea does not stand up.

Comment Re:Pretty neat, like, academically. (Score 1) 88

I see no reason why Ginux or something like it cannot replace Linux in many situations.

For example, there are millions of Linux kernels running on millions of VMs. Most of the time the applications on top don't need all of the features of Linux, if something far smaller, quicker to boot and perhaps faster comes along why would we not use?

For example embedded systems where much the same applies.

How about hundreds of different Ginux like kernels each custom written to run a specific thing on a specific hardware. Small, fast, simple.

Comment Re:Communists (Score 5, Insightful) 29

Americans are so funny. They think civilised behaviour is communist.

I'm all for free speech and all. We should all be able to express our opinions our likes and dislikes etc, But that does not mean I want a world full of lies and misinformation.

Well, Americans would be funny if the effects of their madness did not put us all in danger.

Slashdot Top Deals

"A complex system that works is invariably found to have evolved from a simple system that worked." -- John Gall, _Systemantics_

Working...