Comment Re:That doesn't seem right. (Score 1) 628
Life by itself is not valuable. Bacteria are alive -- that doesn't stop me from washing my hands before I eat.
Life by itself is not valuable. Bacteria are alive -- that doesn't stop me from washing my hands before I eat.
...and this line of thought applies to *most* colleges, and most of the colleges getting shafted in the funding process aren't historically black. There are just a lot of colleges out there (mostly crappy), of all colors.
The institution of a grant applicant matters a *lot* (probably more than the scientific merit of the grant application itself or the applicant writing it). The vast majority of funding goes to the largest, most famous, and (in a somewhat circular manner) most successful research universities. Due to this skewing, if that small pool of top-ranked schools have relatively few black faculty, then the funding will end up going to faculty who aren't black.
From my experience in academia, this seems like a "pirates prevent global warming" situation -- there may be a correlation, but probably not a causative one. There is *definitely* bias in how grants are awarded, but it's bias toward specific institutions rather than a racial bias (given that color is hard or impossible to infer from grant application paperwork anyway).
UNIX was not designed to stop you from doing stupid things, because that would also stop you from doing clever things. -- Doug Gwyn