Comment What's actually asinine ... (Score 2) 261
A pass / fail / no report first semester is very common in the top universities in the country (e.g. - MIT, Harvard, Johns Hopkins University, etc.) and has been for decades. My first semester at JHU back in 1995 was all pass / fail, although you could still make honor roll, etc.
These students are just nominally adults, some have never even been away from home without parental supervision, and most have never had to manage their daily schedule entirely by themselves before.
Giving them a bit of grace and allowing them a couple of months to adjust to an entirely new adult environment -- plus all the new social dynamics that they are encountering for the first time -- is not at all asinine.
What's asinine is expecting all these young kids to be able to immediately adapt to a foreign environment while still performing academically at their top level.