Comment Re: This is a good thing (Score 1) 90
the inspections a hotel are subject to like fire and safety are the same as any other business
This is true, but only for short-term rentals that are being operated in occupancies zoned commercial. In my small town, all of our AirBnB and similar STR's are in residential occupancies, meaning they have never been subject to commercial fire code before the owner started renting them, and have flown totally under the state Fire Marshall's radar. So while you are quite right that the requirements are the same, the onus is 100% on the property owner to meet these requirements, unless the municipality has some way to identify properties operating as STR's–which is exactly what AirBnB is finally providing here.
I'm part of the fire department in my community, and we resorted to looking up offerings in our town on AirBnB and working together as a department to identify the properties by the pictures, all so we could make sure we had pre-fire plans for multi-family occupancies that were popping up in privately-owned homes. While this very well may be a tax grab in NYC, in other communities, identifying STR's is a legitimate public safety concern.