Give a kid a Windows PC and they learn how to use Windows. Give a kid a ChromeBook and they learn how to use the Internet. At least the Windows kid will have learned something they can use later in life.
You're both wrong. Give a kid a Windows PC and they learn how to use Windows to launch an application, and use that application.
Give a kid a Chromebook and they learn how to use ChromeOS to launch an application, and use that application.
Give a kid an iPad and they learn how to use iOS to launch an application, and use that application.
Either way the OS is such a minimal part of the lesson, it's the application itself that provides the meaningful skill. It makes very little difference to the learning whether that application is written in VB.Net and presented directly from the OS, or written in JavaScript and presented through a web browser.
See: Microsoft Word vs Word Online, Photoshop vs Pixlr, etc. Sure in some cases native applications are more powerful, but like it was mentioned above, the overwhelming majority (especially at lower grades) don't need that kind of power.
Also, regardless of the device, that "they learn how to use the internet" is one of the absolute most important things they do. Sure it might not go on a resume, but being able to find and verify information on the internet is one of the most important life skills out there.
but I'll still take it over the android way, my inlaws get a new Samsung note every other year and every time it's a totally new learning curve trying to find where all the settings got moved to this time.
I know you can install your own launcher on android and get mostly the same experience, (used to use Nova Launcher and highly reckoned it) but like I said all the settings pages, where the buttons are and what they do etc, there's no good reason to mess with that and yet everyone but ios always seems to. (Even Mac OS is guilty of it so I'm not totally defending apple either)
The correct solution is to treat services like that as common carriers. If there is bad stuff happening on the service, use existing legal processes to subpoena logs or whatever and go after the actual "bad" guys.
"I've seen the forgeries I've sent out." -- John F. Haugh II (jfh@rpp386.Dallas.TX.US), about forging net news articles