
IANAL...
I'm sure this depends on your location, but here in Canada theft is theft, it is irrelevant if you lock things up. If someone comes onto my physical property and takes something that is theft. Whether there was a lock on the door or a window open is irrelevant. I don't see why it would be any different in the cyber-world.
Now if I have a big sign on the front yard that said "free lawnmower" and then someone came on my property and took the lawnmower I would imagine that I'd have a hard time saying it was theft. But if they took my chainsaw at the same time, that would still be theft, even if it was sitting right next to the lawnmower. I think that analogy is similar to what may have happened here (not exact I understand, hence "analogy"). I get a sign (URL) that points to a page that gives me my information as intended (in my example, lawnmower). If I use that to "get into the database" and then happen to take someone else's information (in my example, chain saw) then that would still be theft would it not? I've been granted access to the database to get my information but not someone else's. The fact that it is sitting right there and available to take does not mean it is "legal" to take it.
Cheers.
No one has commented on the fact that $1.5B / 150,000 homes is $10,000 per house served. That seems ridiculously high to me. I have no numbers to compare to but that seems high.
From http://moneycentral.msn.com/content/SavingandDebt/P87298.asp it gives $1400 per year as the average power bill. Let's assume 50% profit margin since there aren't any consumables: 50% going to infrastructure, salaries, maintenance, paying off lawsuits about dead birds, migraines,
So how is this a good deal? How can anyone make money with those numbers? Poke some holes in my assumptions because it just doesn't make any sense.
I think you just answered the question about why people might pay more for an Apple laptop than go for the absolute lowest deal. If you count your time as $0/hour (as apparently you do) then the sticker price rules the decision. But if your time is non-zero cost then suddenly the equation changes. My laptop is for paying work. If I count that as $100/hour and a reboot costs me 5 minutes then it takes [ $(1000 - 300) / ($1.666/min ) / (5 minutes / reboot) = ] 84 reboots to break even. That's not that many if you use the computer every day to do real work. Then take other support issues, additional software that you might have to purchase, reliability,
You may also throw environmental issues into the equation. While Apple isn't perfect at this they have more info available than most and I trust they are being audited a bit more intensely than some Chinese firm that may or may not make any claims whatsoever.
I guess the conclusion is that sticker price isn't the only cost. There are many others and in a lot of them Apple is way ahead.
BTW, I have all kinds of computers: PC's with Windows and Linux and Mac's too. Whatever is best for the job. So I'm no fanboy either way.
There are never any bugs you haven't found yet.