Comment 10 Years for Copyrights, Patents, and Trademarks (Score 1) 309
Not that I expect it to ever happen, I'd like to see two things:
1) I would love to see 10 years -- 10 years for copyrights, patents, and to a certain degree, trademarks. Yes, even trademarks. A business name (like Microsoft) or a person's name (like an J.K. Rowling) should distinguish between "the real" deal and "a knockoff". (A business name trademark would be permanent.) My argument is this: if someone wants to make a better Mickey Mouse, then why not? If I can create a Mickey Mouse that makes me money, why shouldn't I? It's not like anyone will confuse my Mickey Mouse with Disney's. If a parents wants to show a wholesome movie (instead of an explicit one) to their kids, they can look for the Disney brand. Another example: If I want to make a Star Wars movie, why shouldn't I? So long as I don't say or imply that my works are from Lucas Arts or Disney, I don't see a problem with that? There's nothing stopping Disney / Lucas Arts from making their movies. They can out market me anyway... as long as they give society what they want. (This is what copyrights, patents, and trademarks are pretty much about: giving society what they want.)
2) If you have something to copyright, patent, or trademark, then you must set a price and everyone gets the same deal. If I invent a widget and patent it, I cannot stop my competitors from using it... as long they pay me the price that everyone else is paying. No favoritism. If I write code and copyright it (through $government copyright system), then everyone can use my code after paying me a certain price. My allies can work closely with me on improvements before I copyright it, so we may have an advantage over the next iteration of my product, but after all is said and done, everyone will be able to use it. No hording. No holding back on technology because you want to sit on a patent and hurt everyone else.
After the 10 years expires, it's a free for all. You're free to copy and use it for personal and business use. This applies to movies, books, drug creation (in the pharmaceutical industries), car design, electronics, furniture, space ships, and pretty much anything else you can think of.
Are there problems with my ideas? Yes. Do I have all the answers to make this work perfectly? No. I'd like to see others flush it out, but overall, I think society would gain a tremendous boost of creativity, technological advancement, and companies would still make lots of money in those 10 years. It would also open up a lot of opportunities for the little guy and that's where the best creativity usually comes from.