Comment Re:This is a good thing. (Score 1) 369
With this model they go to world class Athletes with 5% body fat and tell them they are fat because they should weigh xyz, but they weight is abc because of muscle mass.
You and I both know this isn't likely to happen with a world-class athlete. When I hear people talking about how BMI is junk, I assume they are a fat person trying to justify why the medical community is wrong about how overweight they are. As if the average person should be compared to a world-class athlete in any metric. Anyways, there are folks within the medical and statistical communities who do understand the limitations of BMI. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... That being said, there is a strong correlation between disease and those who are rank as either overweight or obese on the BMI scale: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/bo....