Comment Re:It is ethical (Score 1) 826
Bingo! If I had mod points, I'd mod you up!
I've been practicing environmental law for a long time in the U.S., mostly offering help to manufacturers with land use, impact assessment and pollution control permitting for new projects (from the 1980 Winter Olympics to the new $5.4 BLN GlobalFounderies plant).
20 years ago, my actual clients were plant managers for the new facility - mostly chemists and engineers. They knew their shit and knew that I did too. Working with them was a pleasure...even though the permitting costs could often be expensive when we tried to comply with regulations rather than avoid them, they were happy as long as the results were good -- that we were awarded the permits and that the litigation by the NIMBYs was swatted away successfully.
When things started to get dodgy in 2008, I was working on a huge energy project with hedge funded nincompoops who only knew MBA type stuff. They were puzzled and annoyed at the permitting requirements (hyrdoelectric projects require federal licensing, extensive multi-year studies of impact on fisheries in the project area). The project and developers went "poof" after Lehman Bros collapse and the panic of '08.
Now I'm not working much anymore. There is no work, except for really small stuff (lenders foreclose on bankrupt "jiffy lube" with leaking tanks, HOA puzzled by chemical permitting issues for swimming pool chlorine tanks, etc.).
Anyway, agree with your main point. MBAs only understand finance, stock pumping/dumping and the like. They have no clue about the underlying technical issues.