I have kept my family self-insured for years because I contracted, kicked off and sold start-ups. With a pre-existing condition (PTSD, and also the most horrible, needing Zyrtec for allergies) made getting self insurance pretty darn difficult even on plans that exempted mental health. Yes, I heard "we don't cover mental health, but underwriting has declined coverage because of your PTSD."
Fast forward to now: My family of four was PPO insured for $296 a month, $10,000 oop max $5,000 oop individual max, 20% co-pay, free kids' preventive care. It didn't cover maternity (I'm snipped dag-nammit) nor pediatric dental, but in all other aspects exceeded the ACA "Bronze" level plan.
But it was a direct plan. Insurance (CareFirst/BCBS) company cancels group.
Replacement: $690 was the lowest cost plan at the "Bronze" level PPO, which gives us $13900 oop max, $7000 oop individual max, 25 or 30% copay, no included kids' preventive care or immunizations, it rolls in with everything else. We do get maternity. And I get to pay for kids' dental TWICE, since dental insurance is either a family package or per individual.
So basically I get to pay almost $5000 per year more for less. My aggregate income tax rate where I live now 39%. Some places in Canada (okay, Alberta) are the same. California is much higher, with tax loads surpassing that of Germany.
So why should I bother kicking off another start-up here, or keep the ones I have running where they are?
I now pay the same, still get bills for medical services rendered six months ago stamped "overdue" from 4 different providers for a single doctor's visit, and get to sort the mess out all on my own. The ACA threw most self-insured people under the bus - "but hey, no pre-existing conditions anymore, so you get to pay the same as a smoker twice your age with asthma!"