Comment This is a useful enumeration (Score 2, Insightful) 86
Nevertheless, Zed's enumeration can be extremely valuable in helping a discerning reader (who doesn't already know it all!) to critically interpret graphs in order to decide what s/he may conclude. For example, if system X appears to outperforms system Y, but the difference may be within the (unpresented) deviation, one should not accept the assertion that X is superior. Instead, one may conclude that X may be better than or comparable to Y.
Zed's article can help some of us tell the difference between lies and truth. That's a good thing. The unfortunate weakness of the article is that the example is not particularly compelling. It simply doesn't illustrate the most important pitfalls.