Comment Opting In / AHS Performance (Score 1) 213
While I completely agree that opting in / choosing add-ons must be left to the home owner, I have had vastly different experiences with AHS than many folks here, apparently. I had a new home built in Texas around 2005 and chose to add AHS to my home mortgage bill. They initially gave me a $25 copay amount for parts and labor which went up to $75/incident a year later. I lived in that house for 11 years and used AHS several times a year in that time to repair my A/C compressor, replace a water heater, snake plumbing lines, replace a built-in microwave, repair a washing machine, address in-house plumbing leaks and more. AHS more than paid for itself albeit not every claim was fully paid.
This is in stark contrast to the home warranty I obtained with the purchase of an older house in Alaska a year ago. It came Choice Home Warranty for 2.5 years and features a $40 copay. I've tried to use them about a dozen times and they've only paid a couple of claims. In every case the home warranty paid little to nothing and extended the outage of each issue. AHS was great, by comparison. Your mileage may vary. I concur with previous posts and comments recommending a small nest egg for home repairs.