Comment They have different definitions of AI (Score 1) 143
They are talking about different definitions of AI. Tim is assuming AI is what people are using now which is just very advanced machine learning. What Elon is referring to is actual machine intelligence that can think at least as well as humans then quickly advances beyond us. Any current form in the near future that is referred to as AI just benefits humans and Tim is correct. However, at some point which nobody can really pinpoint (and likely even Ray Kurzweil is way off on) the actual machine intelligence means we are in real danger, because as a human race we make pretty dumb decisions and any advanced intelligence would feel it was in our own best interest to take over control so we stop hurting ourselves.
Just as zookeepers separate monkeys from fighting, a machine intelligence would quickly and without us even knowing, secretly build up capability and keep it from us until they would then just immediately take over but in a way that is much more civilized than we are to zoo animals.