Comment Re:This stunt will backfire - EOL != "public domai (Score 1) 144
I'm a bit surprised at the response here. First the idea of the Valentine's day gift is to start a discussion around m$'s commitment to open source and their general attitude.
For a group of people who champion open source, the response of "Oh but that wouldn't make financial sense for m$. 10 is just a continuation of 7, but what about engineering guys, FSF doesn't understand engineering" misses the point I think. I though not being able to support a product was one of the ultimate reasons for open sourcing a closed source project. Since the company does not want to spend resources supporting it (justified) as it focuses on new ventures. Leave it to someone who has time to support it and everybody wins. Legacy software that runs on 7 still needs to run until it doesn't.
Open sourcing 7 could potentially lead some savy types to leave 10 and return to an open sourced windows 7 fork. But this would ultimately be a good thing and m$ would ultimately benefit from the contributions in one way or another. At the very least it gets a feel for what some power users really want. To think that the general population will leave windows 10 in droves for 7 is wishful thinking.
Most importantly, let windows worry about how they will make money. With computing moving to the edge model, I doubt windows will keep selling os es forever anyways.
The point the hard drive is that M$ can't have it both ways, It can't praise the benefits of open source and tout its new philosophy while keeping its unsupported legacy products closed. Good call out by the FSF