Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
Get HideMyAss! VPN, PC Mag's Top 10 VPNs of 2016 for 55% off for a Limited Time ×

Comment Totally Missed the Point... (Score 1) 214

Scratch is good for very young kids that aren't even proficient enough at TYPING. That would be the first major barrier the Scratch could overcome. When you work in scratch - there is no "syntax" to learn - because it's all tactile. Imagine a second-grader who drops a semicolon and starts trying to interpret an error message given at compile time on the FOLLOWING line due to it...

Comment "From the makers of Pippin..." (Score 0, Troll) 129

Apple is so tied-up in giving you what they want to give you, that they have no interest in giving you what they want. Even as a TV console - can I play videos from a USB stick? Can I play via my computer without some convoluted iTunes tie-in? Can I get content from places other than the iTunes store? The answers to all these (at least historically) have been "no" - they're selling you their dream of "streamlining your experience" by doing everything as controlled by them - through them. They can't even build a decent TV-box - and now they want to be a game-console, ignoring everything about how gamers play and insisting on their rules/their way? The utter arrogance...

Comment Re:I'm a HW engineer, I understand firmware fine. (Score 3, Informative) 177

(I am an embedded systems engineer - so I understand it quite well). What might not be evident is that the people that build these routers (often/usually) don't design all the chips in them. i.e. they're made by other companies. The datasheets are available to others. People do this like crazy all the time. There was just an article the other day on how people modified the firmware in a WiFi router radio component to create a WiFi jammer.

Comment Re:Firmware is not software (Score 5, Insightful) 177

Just because YOU don't understand it, it doesn't mean that there are a LOT of people that do and would. I'm not knowledgeable enough to personally audit open-source encryption software like GPG and OpenSSL, but I'm glad it's open-source so others who are more knowledgeable than me can scrutinize.

Comment Licencing, and the new "SDR" (Score 1) 242

I can see the logic here - the FCC regulates the airwaves be licencing the devices on them (*OR* licencing the operators, in the case of ham radio). The rule is, devices must be approved an may not be modified. (Those withe ham licences can build and/or modify, because THEY are required to force the rules, whereas with a licensed device the device itself must "enforce the rules").

I don't think the FCC is arguing that they don't want people's own distribution running along side a WiFi device, but rather, as WiFi chipsets become more "Software Defined" - rewriting the code in them is essentially the same as "modifying the radio".

The best analogy are the RTL HDTV over-the-air capture dongles for software defined radios. Guess what? They're generic radios which only do TV decoding via software - so people write NEW code and suddenly you can use them to do (and I dare say ANYTHING) that any sort of radio receiver could ever be made to do.

This is okay (and legal) with a receiver - they just don't want to to happen with transmitters. What would happen if anyone could do anything they want on the airwaves?

The counterargument is going to be "but they're not cracking down on MODIFYING the radio - just leaving the radio OPEN to being modified". This is expressly prohibited (and has been for a very long time) by the FCC - long before software-defined stuff. Lots of devices like Family-Band radios (and other licensed transmitters) are REQUIRED to be manufactured with things like "non-replaceable antennas" - which make user-modifications more difficult, because they are prohibited (unless done by a [ham] licensed operator).

Slashdot Top Deals

"All the people are so happy now, their heads are caving in. I'm glad they are a snowman with protective rubber skin" -- They Might Be Giants

Working...