Who gets the money's derived from patents and new ideas is of little importance except to the parties concerned. Clearly an enormous amount of money and other resources are wasted in legal fees that might otherwise be spent on research, development and invention. On the other hand this is a rich country and the real issue is whether or not the constitutional goals of the patent system have been compromised: ... to promote the progress of science and useful arts by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.
This argument is similar to the discussion of medical malpractice lawsuits . The goal is clearly to design a system that encourages good medical care for as many people as possible as well as caring for those harmed by human and system errors. Sadly many, perhaps most people are financially motivated so the problem becomes how can we use financial carrots and sticks to align with good policy.