I share the view with you.
What I don't see from endless conversation on "Whether a degree/certificate in IT is good/a must/necessary or not", is that people don't try to quantify things.
Of course degrees prove that you are consistent in pursuing one track, you are smart enough not to fail more than the limit for some exams, and you know some other classmates who would show you (or your boss) how to lead an IT career.
Of course certificates prove that you are serious in building your credits, you have planned to achieve them, and you are proficient enough not to fail at some point.
Of course experience shows that you are ready for the job, you have (also) a consistent track, you have finished some great projects, and you know competent people to keep updating of how the real world IT is running.
All the three above mentioned dimensions count to your IT career. Then the question is how much do they count for your currently interviewed job.
- Do your future employer rely on your degree/certificate to "advertise" their team. (Example: "We are a team of highly qualified/educated people, then our product must be good")
- Do they want someone ready immediately at day-1 to help the cash pouring into their pocket
- Do they want some who can learn fast, and contribute to their team from a different perspective (This applies to some "Good-degree-no-experience" cases)
Give each axe a weight, see how much they match your future employer, and estimate your chance. For example if > 70% of IT professionals have an IT university-or-above degree, and your future employer is an "average IT company", then it should be: "Things are alot easier with a degree".
Thanks