Comment Too good play looks like inspiration. (Score 2, Interesting) 108
I do not believe in charges of cheating based solely on the moves chosen. To Good play is indistinguishable from inspiration. I believe that physical evidence or witness evidence should be required. To do otherwise would be to deny the possibility of inspiration or to only accept it when it assumes a given form.
Cheating based on choice of moves is the very definition of speculative evidence. It assumes that humans know where thought and knowledge comes from. We do not.