Comment Re:Arwen--what? (Score 1) 253
It should be a flashback ...
Aragorn having a talk with Elrond about himself and Arwen happen quite a while before FOTR if you read the appendices.
"And do you think (fop that I am) that I could be the Scarlet Pumpernickel?" -- Looney Tunes, The Scarlet Pumpernickel (1950, Chuck Jones)