Thanks for your open and honest discussion. I think at least one major difference is that I experienced things in Europe, with many separate governments doing their things, and many different specialists, politicians, etcetera, explaining things. The vaccines were shown to be safe and effective, preventing infection (but indeed not 100%, which wasn't openly stated but I got the right expectation, though many others didn't and commented that the claims they heard from specialists were as you said, though here they weren't), reducing the need to isolate and lock down, and no, I didn't see that claim about being better than natural immunity around here anywhere. I clearly recall lots of wishful thinking, mostly by politicians and the media coverage, which lots of what you have said falls into. So I get your point. I've just experienced things differently. In your shoes, I would probably be very hesitant about any specialist and politician's message too, though never to the point of applauding anything RFK though, there are limits...
What was most important to me, was the percentage of ICUs available, and in all of the countries I kept track of, this was managed, though in many cases very much just. Italy had a short moment in various regions where they sadly had to do triage, though luckily only very briefly.
One thing I found out later, is that many who were critical about loads of countermeasures were also in 2022 of the opinion that Ukraine belongs to Russia and Putin. So then it became clear they got their news off of Russia Today, Telegram and similar sources, which explains why many of those who would normally not think as much about many things suddenly got so verbal about things they don't have much understanding about ...