Comment Experience with homeschooling and public schooling (Score 1) 700
We home schooled both of our kids for some period of time - the oldest until he was a 4th grader, and the youngest, until she was a 2nd grader. We did not do it for religious or "clingy" reasons - we did it because where we initially lived had very poor schools, with issues of gang activity and violence.
Our oldest was the youngest in his class when he was first placed in public school. And then was skipped yet ahead another grade. This was due not only to his academic standing, but his maturity. Likewise, we had the opportunity to allow the same with our daughter, but did not. Why? Most of our sons friends were in the grade above him, and most of our daughters friends were in the grade she entered into.
Both are friendly, warm . . . normal. Our son was awarded a full-ride to our region's flagship University and is doing well. He is slightly nerdy (he received a 36 on his ACT), but is also into sports - loves racquetball. Our daughter has a 4.0+, runs cross country, and is considering Harvey Mudd for her post-high school education. She is into science and math.
BUT - and here is the big caveat . . . both my wife and I have teaching degrees, with my wife having a Master's in Education. We are also very technologically proficient . . . and active in science.
The outcome of our kids, I don't believe, was vastly impacted by the home schooling . . . they entered public school at a relatively young age. I think basic parenting is the main skill needed . . . 90% of societies issues are due to bad parenting at some level.