Comment Sort of (Score 1) 26
Right to repair is gaining momentum, but it keeps getting watered down to the point of almost being useless.
Case in point - Colorado. They passed one of the better right to repair laws not terribly long ago. Just recently Cisco and IBM dumped $600k into lobbying in that state, and all of a sudden that law now has an exemption carved out for "critical infrastructure." Which sounds nice on the surface, but it allows the manufacturer to define which devices are critical infrastructure. They can point to any of their devices and cry "Critical infrastructure!" and now that device is exempt from that right to repair law. That exemption hasn't been fully signed into law yet, to my knowledge. It passed committee (unanimously), and is up for a full vote..... I'm not sure when.
But this is the kind of crap that keeps happening everywhere that right to repair laws exist, or are trying to be passed. Until either we get money out of politics (one can dream, right?), and/or politicians grow some stones and tell these lobbyists to pound sand, it's not going to amount to much. I think we all know the likelihood of either of those things happening though.
Case in point - Colorado. They passed one of the better right to repair laws not terribly long ago. Just recently Cisco and IBM dumped $600k into lobbying in that state, and all of a sudden that law now has an exemption carved out for "critical infrastructure." Which sounds nice on the surface, but it allows the manufacturer to define which devices are critical infrastructure. They can point to any of their devices and cry "Critical infrastructure!" and now that device is exempt from that right to repair law. That exemption hasn't been fully signed into law yet, to my knowledge. It passed committee (unanimously), and is up for a full vote..... I'm not sure when.
But this is the kind of crap that keeps happening everywhere that right to repair laws exist, or are trying to be passed. Until either we get money out of politics (one can dream, right?), and/or politicians grow some stones and tell these lobbyists to pound sand, it's not going to amount to much. I think we all know the likelihood of either of those things happening though.