Comment UK Imessage suddenly unavailable would focus minds (Score 2) 181
Can you see Apple doing a UK only version of Imessage? Not a chance. Not only because its a pain in the rear re: legal, code, which phones are to be be targeted etc but more importantly, once they cave to one Western government, it will be all of them asking for the same thing.
All Apple would have to do is say "Sorry, no Imessage because UK government wants to snoop on your stuff and we don't want to let them" and the government would about turn so fast that they would break the sound barrier.
Also it's a certain amount of BS on the governments part because most Police action is intelligence led and secondly, failure to surrender a password makes you liable for up to two years inside. They have the tools to fix this, they just want more power.
Oh and no one has told them... Major criminal orgs will just create their own encryption using COTS encryption libraries. You cant "undo encryption" and put it back in its bottle.