Comment Plus ça change? (Score 1) 90
People call AI training "theft." Historical reality check: The legendary Library of Alexandria was the original non-consensual dataset scrape. Around 240 BC, Ptolemy III made the library the world’s knowledge hub through pure imperial muscle:
(1) Mandatory Port Seizures: Customs raided every docking ship for books, returned hurried hand-written copies, and kept the originals.
(2) Deposit Fraud: "Borrowed" Athens' master play scripts with a massive silver deposit, then forfeited the cash to keep the original master copies.
(3) Market Monopolies: Aggressively hoarded scrolls across the Mediterranean.
We romanticize Alexandria as a temple of pure learning, but its foundation was state-backed intellectual looting. Every leap in aggregating global human knowledge looks strikingly similar in the rearview mirror.