Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:It's an "ology"! (Score 3) 230

Your statement is a bit too harsh.

Parapsychology has a lot of problems from a reproducible experiment POV, but many of them are due to a complete lack of theory as to how a possible mechanism for a given extra-sensory phenomenon might work. Without a working theory, how do you develop an experiment to test it?

Couple of examples to illustrate the difficulties:

I am an ancient experimenter. I have lots of black rocks. One or two of the black rocks attract one another, but the vast majority do not. (the ones that do are lodestones, natural magnets) I publish a paper saying that some black rocks attract one another. Other experimenters get black rocks and cannot reproduce my experiment. Jamius Randius says I'm a fake, and even when I demonstrate black rocks that attract one another, says I am a huckster. An investigating committee bangs my black rocks together, making them lose their magnetism, so even I cannot make them attract anymore. I lose my patron, and rocks that attract one another is branded pseudo-science.

Other experimenters try this out with other black rocks, but so few have successful results that future researchers need to depend on meta-analysis of thousands of experiments to get possibly statistically meaningful results. Statistics is hard, so the research descends into sniping about statistical techniques. (See http://therandomtexan.wordpress.com/2013/11/14/the-beginning-of-the-end-for-5/ for recent discussions about how p values are too loose across many disciplines.)

Second example closer to home in parapsychology. There are thought experiments proposing that all ESP related phenomena like remote viewing or telepathy may just be specific cases of precognition, since validating experimental results involves knowing the outcome at some point in the future.

Last idea: Since parapsychological phenomena (whether 'real' or not) involve people and effects at a distance, how to ensure the experimenter is not having an effect on the experiment. This is one idea behind the 'sheep/goat' effect in parapsychology (other explanation is that all sheep are cheating and all goats are honest experimenters)

it's a really interesting field that rewards study, just in terms of figuring out how to create good experiments in such a vacuum. Govt. research and specifically application to gathering intelligence has always been saddled with extremely low reproducibility but occasional spectacular successes.

Comment Re:Major fail for Tesla (Score 5, Insightful) 161

Classic failure mode for companies that do not primarily write software, bur use software in their products. We are seeing more and more of the continued use of security through obscurity followed by goggle-eyed amazement that haxors would figure out a way to penetrate the systems of the device/vehicle/airplane/whatever, finally ending in lawsuits to attempt to hide the existence of grotesque security failures. I cannot wait for the first corporation to be sued for insecure product design.

Comment NSA dragnet vs. your own email server (Score 2) 301

I think there is a lot to be said for running your own email server to avoid the warrantless dragnet of stored emails at major ISP's. (assuming the ISP's will pass the port 25 traffic along)

Maybe the fiber taps at all the US based network exchange points makes running your own email server less of a defense, but at least the ISP's would not have the ability to turn over your emails all tied up with a bow.

Make the spooks work for their packets!

Comment Why can't anyone build to this spec? (Score 1) 106

Grrr! All E-reader designers: rinse, lather, repeat:
  1. Take your favorite O'Reilly book.
  2. Open it up and measure it's size.
  3. Make a folding E-Reader that is the same size as the O'Reilly book closed that opens up like a book
  4. In landscape mode show two pages, one on each display, in portrait mode show a single page spanning both. (gives you newspaper/magazine page access)
  5. Make it e-ink only so I can read it outside and so it does not kill my eyes and so the battery lasts a while.
  6. Do NOT tie it to some stupid store/publishing service, or if you do, make sure I can just load content to it without passing through your service.
  7. Sell it for lots less than a laptop.
  8. Profit! sell lots to geeks that want to carry their entire tech library in something the size of one book.

Comment Hands on display at NSA Museum, Ft. Meade (Score 4, Interesting) 175

Last time I was there, you could play with one of these at the National Cryptoglogic Museum near Ft. Meade in Maryland, URL: http://www.nsa.gov/museum/

THis place is _really_ worth a visit. The staff are all retired NSA staff and are glad to talk to you about the exhibits (now that the equipment is declassified!) They have an excellent exhibit on Cold War era supercomputers, with a Cray and a Connection Machine CM-5 on display.

Slashdot Top Deals

Hotels are tired of getting ripped off. I checked into a hotel and they had towels from my house. -- Mark Guido

Working...