Submission + - When Appliances Attack: Industry Groups Paint Dark Picture of Right to Repair
The bill HB 462 (HB 462 (https://legiscan.com/NH/text/HB462/id/1842976), ) is sponsored by NH Rep. David Luneau (http://www.gencourt.state.nh.us/house/members/member.aspx?member=377307), an MIT graduate with degrees in Electrical Engineering and Computer Science. It is similar in scope to right to repair bills filed in 16 other states, from Massachusetts to Hawaii (https://r2rsolutions.org/news/update-tracking-right-repair-legislation-across-50-states/)). It would require original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) that do business in New Hampshire to make the same documentation, parts and tools available to device owners and independent repair professionals as they make available to their licensed or “authorized” repair professionals. Documentation, tools, and parts needed to reset product (software) locks or digital right management functions following maintenance and repair would also need to be made available to owners and independent repair professionals on “fair and reasonable terms.
But that didn't stop industry groups and their lawyers from arguing that there will be dark times in the Granite State should the bill become law. At a hearing NH House's Commerce and Consumer Affairs Committee, lawmakers heard that curious children could find themselves dismembered by run-away washing machines. Industry reps warned that a illegally modified lawn tractors and leaf blowers could belch pollution in defiance of the EPA.
Representatives from a wide range of industries opposing the legislation filled a small hearing room in the New Hampshire state house. They included the Association of Equipment Manufacturers, wireless industry group CTIA, TechNet, the technology industry lobby, the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM) and more. Their message: repairs performed by the owners of lawn equipment, electronics and home appliances or independent repair professionals carry serious economic, safety and security risks.
Christina Fisher, the Executive Director for Massachusetts and the Northeast at technology industry lobby TechNet said the right to repair bill was “legislation in search of a problem." The servicing of home security and other smart devices make repair a “life or death” issue, she warned, adding that New Hampshire would be branded an “anti competitive” state if it passed the law.
“There is a lot at stake when it comes to Right to Repair, and you could feel those stakes in the room,” Nathan Proctor, the head of the right to repair campaign (https://uspirg.org/feature/usp/right-repair) at the US Public Interest Research Group (PIRG), told The Security Ledger. “Legislators have their work cut out for them sifting through all the frantic opposition and their deceptive, and at times bizarre, arguments,” he wrote.
Right to repair legislation was defeated in 17 states in 2018, with most bills failing to make it out committee. (https://repair.org/legislation/). The same forces are lining up to square off against the legislation in 2019, said Gay Gordon-Byrne of the Repair Coalition. (https://www.repair.org)
“There is the same opposition, same arguments, and often the same lobbyists at all of these hearings,” wrote Gay Gordon-Byrne, Executive Director of the Repair Association in an email. “The larger problem is not the lobbyist testimony at hearings, which are often laughable, but the behind the scenes damage done by opposition.”