Comment Re:Good (Score 1) 70
Replays have been in place for years, and I think arguments between the coaches and umpires have probably gone way down in response to calls that aren't about the strike zone. Since they can't get rid of bad umps because of the umpire union, they'll have to do this to minimize the PR impact of certain bad umps. Unfortunately, it won't improve MLBs problems which are teams focusing on winning by taking more pitches, and their decision to put their product on expensive cable networks which bring more product but prevent younger fans from being exposed to their product, reducing the number of people interested in their product, ensuring that fewer people will care about baseball in the generations to come. Eventually, immigration from countries that care about soccer more will probably lead to MLS being the second-largest sport in the US.
I think the NFL, for now, has the right idea, because every Sunday, most of the country can watch 4 games on CBS, Fox and NBC, meaning most fans can watch 25% of NFL games without a significant financial investment. It also helps that Football has 269 games, meaning a full season of football has about 810 hours of action. If I watch 2 games a week, (many fans quite easily watch 5 (3 on Sunday - early afternoon, late afternoon and evening, plus Monday and Thursday), I'm watching 12% of the action in a season, and somebody watching 5 games is getting around 30%. To do the equivalents in baseball, for 12%, you'd have to watch 2 games a day, at 6 hours, and for 30% you'd have to watch 5 for about 15 hours per day. The ability to consume more of a football season with less of a time commitment probably leads to more interest because of familiarity with the game and players.