I wouldn't be surprised if that was the case. Of course, as any fool knows the only real solution to piracy is to offer your product to consumers at a price they are willing to pay, and in a format they see as value, so the Supreme Court can rule however they like. It will make no difference to the real world.
Also to be given the option to have said product without DRM and own it. steam, epic john deere etc and companies like c apcom who wont release physical discs for pc are one of the reasons why people turn to piracy.
Yes, but it's the equivalent of telling my attorney he or she can't look up the license plate of the car that ran me over.
That's not equivalent because that would both make sense to do and be perfectly legal.
This is the equivalent of *ME* asking the court for permission to lookup the license plate of the car that ran you over, plus a few thousand other license plates of cars that ran a few thousand other people over.
As much as you probably wouldn't mind me doing that, I still probably shouldn't have a legal right to that information.
To be more equivalent, this would need to follow previous requests I've made to do that, been given the license plate info in the police database, then never followed up by using it in a lawsuit.
Once you add that in, not only should I probably not have a legal right to that information, but many people should probably assume I am up to no good with it.
Even if you were able to get the license info though could you prove who was driving the car?
The faster I go, the behinder I get. -- Lewis Carroll