Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: Ah the ecosystem excuse (Score 1) 109

No, just right wing economists. History has demonstrated that Keynes was right all along.

The problem with right wing economists like Friedman is that they started with the conclusion they wanted (let the rich do whatever they want) and then created all these absurd theories to try and justify that conclusion.

Comment Re: Amazing (Score 1) 223

Universal healthcare would bring me happiness, but we do not have that because this dickhead billionaire wanted to make toys that impress suckers like you.

Cool! I am so glad we stopped taxing the rich and then diverted all our defense dollars into their sketchy companies so they can make people excited with tech demos for products that will never actually be sold, and if they were, none of us could afford them anyway.

You are the peasant extolling the beauty of Versaillesâ(TM) architecture and trying to shame us for being pissed off that we have worked hard to create wealth that was squandered in a gorgeous waste of money.

Comment Re: Not Rogue! (Score 1) 43

That was a bit snarky and could lead to an irrelevant technical debate.

I should point out that, most importantly, when OpenAI claims that they air gapped these systems in any way (including just isolating them as a VM with no network device attached), I DO NOT BELIEVE THEM. They have done nothing to suggest that they are being honest about the situation. They only admitted fault when they got caught and then only in such ways that would allow them to weasel out of any legal liability.

It does not matter if an AI system can escape an air gapped system because we have no reason to believe that is what actually happened.

Comment Re: Ax problem (Score 1) 43

Programs do not just randomly do this. The guys at OpenAI knew the capabilities of the software, wrote its instructions, and intentionally ran the program.

They are only claiming these things are rogue because they got caught and they see this absurd claim as a way to avoid liability.

If I wrote a worm, tested it on my local network despite knowing that by design it could escape that local network and cause real damage, and then it did exactly that, no prosecutor, judge, or jury will let me off the hook when I claim I only intended to test it on the local network.

I would love to see the AGENTS.md for this thing. . .

Comment Re: My AI is even MORE EVIL (Score 2) 76

Think of the AIs like employees. If you tell an employee to break the law and they do it, you have both broken the law. If an employee goes rogue and breaks the law in violation of company policy, only the employee broke the law.

The fact of the matter is that they programmed the agents and hooked them up to LLMs they designed, and all of this started with a PROMPT.

I cannot believe for a second that the design of the agent (remember, and agent is just a program that interfaces with an LLM) would do these things if it were not programmed to do so, given particular prompts. I suspect if we were able to see the prompts, the agent tools, the agent instructions, etc. these hacks would not seem rogue at all.

Right now OpenAI is trying to argue that they did not kill someone, the gun they designed and built killed someone and it aimed and pulled the trigger by itself. They want to convince us that the gun had AGENCY, because otherwise actual people are liable for these crimes. Crimes that if you or I committed, we would go to prison for.

Comment Re: I was wondering when FOSS projects would notic (Score 2) 121

These truly are uncharted territories so any overconfident claims about the legal status of LLM-generated anything should be viewed skeptically. Rarely is existing law well equipped to deal with new innovations, so it is doubtful that we will have any answers until new laws are written.

My bet would be that the tech oligarchs will write those laws, so they will probably seem contradictory in that they allow tech oligarchs to do whatever they want with data while placing onerous restrictions on end users.

Slashdot Top Deals

"Wish not to seem, but to be, the best." -- Aeschylus

Working...