They just can't part with the Tevatron . . . this recycling line is just an excuse to keep it around.
Assuming you would want to, it is non-trivial to just dispose of 4 miles of superconducting magnets.
Anyways, the part of the Tevatron that you are most likely to find reuse is the 4 miles of tunnel. The civil construction to dig a tunnel that big, complete with tunnel penetrations and service buildings is a significant portion of the cost of any project. You would be a fool to just fill in such a valuable commodity just because you don't have a use of it today.
And that's ignoring all the parts that are already being scrounged for use in the NoVA upgrades. So no, keeping it around is not merely a case of geek sentiment.
The best things in life go on sale sooner or later.