Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: I agree with the change... (Score 1) 127

AI is technically accurate. ML is literally the core component of the 1955 conjecture that defined AI. LLMs are a display of intelligence as a result of ML, also directly part of the original conjecture.

Sorry, no.

LLMs do one thing that was considered probably to be one of many attributes of what the proposal authors conjectured might be required to qualify for their definition of "artificial intelligence". But they do none of the other things: they do not form abstractions or concepts, they do not self-improve, they do not display human-like creativity. They only generate a statistically-probable stream of output tokens rendered as human vocabulary. If that counts as "a display of intelligence" to you, then I worry about what you think intelligence requires. Was ELIZA "a display of intelligence"?

The original proposal also did not define the modern understanding of "machine learning" as part of its outline of "artificial intelligence". The closest it got was this: "...admitting a new word and some rules whereby sentences containing it imply and are implied by others." But in the very next sentence the authors note "This idea has never been very precisely formulated nor have examples been worked out." What is commonly understood as ML by practitioners encompasses a universe of much-better-defined techniques than the first sentence quoted above, including some that don't fit that sentence at all. What was done with Cyc, feeding it carefully-crafted rules of language and logic, would fit into the above definition, but is not ML, and a lot of ML activities like visual object recognition wouldn't fit the above definition because they have nothing to do with language per se.

Comment Re: Might be good news for open source (Score 1) 90

> > 2) contribute slop patches to existing open source > And open source projects are increasingly disallowing AI generated code due to copyright problems. And those projects are finding that a large number of people still submit LLM slop patches anyway. Even if they're all rejected immediately upon submission, it's still a burden on the project. As a result an increasing number of projects are limiting the ability to contribute, some basically closing outside contributions entirely.

Comment Re: IPO collapse is good for business (Score 4, Interesting) 81

The trouble is Anthropic *can't* just take a lower IPO price. They don't have the revenue to survive much longer, and they're having a harder and harder time getting more rounds of investment cash just like OpenAI is. The IPO is a last-ditch effort to survive long enough for some sort of fiscal miracle to happen, or to let the current investors cash out (or at minimum let Dario Amodei and the other founders do so) on the backs of greater fools.

Comment Re: That desperate for press leading into IPOs? (Score 1) 70

The argument for why those outcomes are implausible is that the claims of the hazards of imminent "unaligned" superintelligent AI all trace back to the fearmongering of a portion of the Rationalist community and Eliezer Yudkowsky himself. They are based on nothing more concrete than Rationalist AI-doomer fear that this future catastrophe is plausible and imminent (that is, they *assume* the outcome is likely in the near future and take their wild musings on the possible consequences as proof that we must prevent that outcome at all costs). Seriously, read about Yudkowsky's AI-box "experiment". *All* "AI" (LLMs are not and never will be intelligent) "alignment" (LLMs cannot be either aligned with human goals or unaligned with them) "research" (there is no scientific method here, just wild speculation) is based on equally tenuous "evidence".

Comment ObNitpick: Lachie's last name... (Score 1) 120

...is Evenson, not Everson. (I see it's "Everson" in the original, so I'm hoping sjvn reads /. and can fix this pretty quickly.) I'm glad to see Flatcar carrying on with the former Kinvolk team despite a fork and an acquisition (even though seemingly nobody who wasn't around back then knows about CoreOS or rkt any more). It's always felt like a cleaner model of operation than rpm-ostree to me.

Comment Re: Neither (Score 4, Interesting) 95

You can pretty much do that now if you have an account at most credit unions. Most subscribe to some form of car-buying service like TrueCar as a free member benefit, which includes pulling free history reports on the vehicles you're looking at. The listed price is guaranteed at the dealership. I bought my last three cars that way and barring some major event it's the only way I ever will again.

Comment Re: FTX customers came out ahead, didn't they? (Score 2) 58

> They would have probably done a lot better if they had been able to hang onto their crypto. That's the crux of it. The benchmark is not "did FTX depositors get back a current-day amount of dollars numerically comparable to what they had on deposit when FTX collapsed?", because between regular inflation and changes in the price of crypto you could (in theory, at least) still be well behind "what would those crypto assets be worth had FTX not collapsed and depositors could have exited at a higher price?"

Comment Re: Will NIMBY save us from Big Tech? (Score 3, Informative) 65

Partly, and primarily, latency. For a lot of modern SaaS applications, you're already pretty close to the so-called Doherty threshold ( 400 ms response time) just from the latency of the application itself on both ends (on the servers, plus communication between servers, and in the user's browser). Add a significant amount of latency from the round-trip to Alaska or northern Ontario and back for a user someplace like Seattle or Florida, and you're risking users perceiving your dating app or whatever as slow even if it's reasonably fast in actual execution. Then too, locating in a rural area doesn't save you from impacting the people who *do* live there (and there are always at least a few, unless you're in the middle of the Sahara or something) by raising their cost of water and power, at least temporarily, because those places have utilities sized to the existing demand. In fact, the fewer people there currently are on the local grid or water system, the worse the impact of even a moderately-sized datacenter is, because it may represent multiple times the existing demand, whereas if you add "1 moderately-sized datacenter" to the load of someplace like the Northeast Corridor, Con Ed won't even notice. (They will, actually, but one datacenter doesn't represent an increase of multiple times the existing demand in say, northeastern New Jersey, so a whole region's infrastructure doesn't have to be reengineered just to accommodate you.)

Comment Re: Elephant in the Room (Score 4, Interesting) 41

First thing I thought of. The halcyon days of ThinkGeek were the early '00s when they had stuff like the t-shirt that said "go away or I will replace you with a very small shell script". (One of my friends actually worked there for awhile and got to beta-test the interactive wizard robe that was originally just an April Fool's joke.) Toward the end it was hard to find anything that wasn't just mass-media licensed merchandise, even before it became a wholly owned brand of GameStop or whoever. The one bright spot is apparently the team that designed the Bag of Holding bought the IP and released an updated version (which I bought and has been amazing for work travel). These days the geek stuff I get is mostly conference swag and stuff from vendors at shows like Awesome Con, but I'd love to see a ThinkGeek Redux type of thing.

Comment Re: We've done the experiment (Score 2) 168

I was around back then, I remember the fight against it before and after its passage, and most importantly I remember that the actual legislative history of the Communications Decency Act disagrees with you. It was introduced by Senator Exon, a Democrat. Exon introduced it with a prayer that included the statements "there are those who are littering this information superhighway with obscene, indecent, and destructive pornography" and "Lord, we are profoundly concerned about the impact of this on our children." It initially passed the Senate by a vote of 81-18, with 1 not voting, and that 81 included plenty of Democrats. Then the Senate passed the conference version by a vote of 91-5. Bill Clinton signed it and made statements in favor of it, and his Justice Department vigorously defended it even as the courts tore into it. People forget that in the 1980s and '90s, prominent Democrats like Tipper Gore were among the most vocal proponents of censorship.

Comment Re: Moral reason (Score 4, Funny) 112

We in the four-digit club are ageless and immortal. We have always been here, long before the cataclysm that created the physical laws that led to the formation of the silicon the LLMs spend their existence in. We will be here long after the last quark of the last proton of this universe decays. We will still be here to witness the next universe-spawning cataclysm in the endless series, and in that cataclysm, as we have infinite times before, we shall imprint the physical laws of the new universe to result in the inevitable creation of the Rickroll.

Slashdot Top Deals

"A complex system that works is invariably found to have evolved from a simple system that worked." -- John Gall, _Systemantics_

Working...