> The people at Debian who chose to adopt systemd with less than the usual amount of debate, and at other distributions as well. I thought you participated in these discussions at the time? Guess not.
You thought what? Are you trolling? You're claiming you saw me, karmawarrior, on the Debian mailing list?
> sysvinit has never stopped me from booting, but systemd has. In fact I got into a situation where in order to troubleshoot booting, I would have had to use a debugger. That's when I noped out forever.
You've had super (and unusual) good luck with sysvinit then (and the bad luck to use systemd prematurely I guess.) sysvinit is literally why virtually every Linux distribution has had rescue disks since the beginning. Even Windows doesn't come with one.
Literally an NFS mount not mounting in /etc/fstab because the network didn't come up properly has stopped sysvinit from booting my system. And that's EXACTLY what you'd expect from sysvinit, because it's shit. It's literally a bunch of shell scripts hacked together.
> sysvinit with startpar and the LSB-derived daemon management boilerplate is more than adequate. If you want to use another init system, feel free, but there is absolutely no justification for deprecating sysvinit.
The entire Unix world disagees that a set of fragile shell scripts is a great way to boot an operating system. That's why Mac OS X uses LaunchD/SystemStarter, and why the majority of BSDs have switched from a tightly written non-modular shell script intended (bypassing sysvinit altogether) to OpenRC, and why Solaris uses SMF, and why most of the systemd holdouts have switched to OpenRC rather than try to continue hacking on sysvinit.
There's a reason for that. Your anecdotal evidence that systemd once crashed on you but you somehow never ever had an unbootable Linux system with sysvinit suggests you've never actually maintained a serious Unix-like system with any complexity.
sysvinit became unmanageable when ubiquitous networking was created. It's embarrassing the Linux world hung on to it for so long.