Comment One extreme to the next (Score 1) 243
The very first time I played the level "Arnhem Knights" in Medal of Honor: Frontline, I was moved to tears. It probably was a combination of the music, gunfire and soldiers dying all over the place but I've never had an experience like that from a FPS before.
I'll also never forget playing "Silent Hill 2," I'm in the old abandoned prison. I was in a bathroom with about 3 or 4 stalls, one of them closed. I "knock" on the closed one and the text on screen said there's no one there. So I knock again, for kicks. Huh, oh well. Start walking away and suddenly a loud BAM BAM BAM from the empty stall. I screamed. Loudly.
There were many other moments in SH2 that freaked me out but none of them gave me that kind of reaction.